Your Source for Amish Baked Goods!

Specialty Butters

  1. Amish Made Apple Butter

    Amish Made Apple Butter

    Yoder's apple butter is a cross between a jam and homemade applesauce and has been a favorite of our restaurant for many years. The rich flavor and wonderful aroma comes from the sweet and heart... Learn More

  2. Amish Made Sugar Free Apple Butter

    Amish Made Sugar Free Apple Butter

    $3.95

    Ingredients Include:


    Apples, Apple Cider, Spice
    Learn More
  3. Amish Made Peanut Butter

    Amish Made Peanut Butter

    $6.95

    This homemade, creamy, marshmallow spread is another favorite of Yoder's Kitchen as well as an old Amish tradition.


    Ingredients Include:


    Pea... Learn More

3 Item(s)

per page

Set Descending Direction